Ensure
the State's Economic Forecasts Take Inflation into Account
Get
the printer-friendly PDF version of this document.
Minnesota's Economic Forecasts, prepared by the Minnesota Department
of Finance in February and November of each year, are an essential
tool for understanding the state's fiscal health. They measure the
state's projected revenues against projected spending under current
law conditions.
The Forecast does not adjust future spending for inflation,
although it does adjust future revenues based on inflation. This
is due to a law passed in 2002 that prohibits including the influence
of inflation on most spending in the Forecast. While it was a reasonable
decision at that time to combat a state budget deficit by restraining
growth in spending, that outcome should have been achieved in budget
legislation, rather than by changing the state's forecasting methods.
It is important to distinguish between providing information
about the cost of maintaining the state's current service levels
and the budget choices about whether to fund an inflationary
increase. Each year, the cost of providing a service generally rises
as the cost of materials, rent, and personnel rises. If the level
of funding remains constant, over time inflation will erode the
state's ability to provide the same level of service.
When the impact of inflation on future spending is not included
in the Forecast, the public and policymakers are given a
mistaken impression of the state's economic future. The
Forecast may imply that there are more resources available for new
initiatives than it would be prudent to spend, or disguise that
the state does not have sufficient resources to meet its current
commitments. Including inflation in the Forecast helps decision-makers
understand whether fiscal decisions are sustainable.
Our Recommendation:
The Minnesota Budget Project recommends taking inflation
into account in the Forecast, by eliminating the provision
in current law that prevents the Department of Finance from doing
so. As was done prior to 2002, the Department of Finance should
include a general inflationary increase in determining the state's
fiscal health in future budget cycles. This would not impact the
"base" funding for state services - in order for a program or service
to receive an increase in its base funding, this increase would
need to be authorized by the Legislature.
Enacting this recommendation would:
- Provide good financial information
about the future cost of the state's commitments.
- Encourage responsible fiscal management by providing a clear understanding of the state's
future fiscal health and whether proposed initiatives are sustainable.
- Maintain flexibility by preserving existing budget authority;
no automatic funding increases are created.
- Encourage accountability
by recognizing the long-term implications of budget decisions.
-
Promote stability by providing the tools needed to make sustainable
budget decisions.
Senate File 25, which passed the Minnesota Senate
on January 26, overturns the 2002 law that forbids the inclusion
of the impact of inflation in the Forecast. SF 25 is consistent
with the Minnesota Budget's Project's recommendations for a better
budget process.
January 2007
|